Is my dog RUDE?! Argh
So I realized on our walk today that Shira may very well be that rude, annoying dog that terrorizes other dogs. She hasn't annoyed any of the neighborhood dogs too much, aside from a gorgeous Weimaraner that gave her a bit of a growl when she wouldn't stop jumping on her head.
I was so worried about curbing dog aggression in the beginning that all I cared about was that she wanted to sniff/play with other dogs. I completely forgot to consider how she approached them.
Whenever Shira spots another dog, depending on her energy level (which is usually sky high no matter how much exercise we get), she will:
a) pull towards them, panting, until she starts choking,
b) pull towards them, until I reel her in and pick her up,
c) pull towards them, until drag her past, or
d) pull towards them, until I ask the other owner if they can sniff, and allow her to meet the dog.
Commence jumping and mauling.
I know Shibas are wrestle-players, but the other dogs seem hesitant about it because she skips the "Good day to you sir!" sniff and just dives right in to the wrestle. Misbehavior of pulling the leash aside, I'm thinking this is rude.
What do you think? Did I create a monster?
What steps could I take to correct her greeting process?
Thanks in advance!
I was so worried about curbing dog aggression in the beginning that all I cared about was that she wanted to sniff/play with other dogs. I completely forgot to consider how she approached them.
Whenever Shira spots another dog, depending on her energy level (which is usually sky high no matter how much exercise we get), she will:
a) pull towards them, panting, until she starts choking,
b) pull towards them, until I reel her in and pick her up,
c) pull towards them, until drag her past, or
d) pull towards them, until I ask the other owner if they can sniff, and allow her to meet the dog.
Commence jumping and mauling.
I know Shibas are wrestle-players, but the other dogs seem hesitant about it because she skips the "Good day to you sir!" sniff and just dives right in to the wrestle. Misbehavior of pulling the leash aside, I'm thinking this is rude.
What do you think? Did I create a monster?
What steps could I take to correct her greeting process?
Thanks in advance!
Comments
I would also stop the leash pulling and diving at the other dog. Work more on a good sit so you can get her to stop and be still. Carry something really interesting if you need to and reward her as soon as she sits still for even a split second. Start out far away from the other dog. Gradually increase how long she stays still and how close the other dog is. Do not let her greet another dog when she's pulling and bouncing on the leash. Only let her greet another dog after she sits even if it isn't for very long. Letting her get all bouncy excited and out of control is only building up her energy and anticipation for getting to the other dog which makes it even more likely she'll just pounce on them instead of greeting calmly first. Sometimes if I have to I'll stand there holding Haru just out of reach while she pulls up on her hind legs and flips around trying to get at a person or dog. We'll stand there as long as we need to until she starts to chill and then she gets to go see the dog or person. However if you haven't previously worked on what's appropriate calm moments and what's appropriate hyper time that exercise could take a very long time with a shiba.
1. As Shawna said - allow other dogs to 'teach' her what is appropriate. As she is still a pup, now is the BEST time for this. It is absolutely true - nothing teaches your dog 'manners' more effectively than another [older] dog.
2. Also like Shawna said - Work on focus training - redirecting her attention to you when she starts to get all pent up at the sight of another dog. Especially if you cannot or do not let her approach, getting her to focus on you instead might help her calm down and give her self control when she sees other dogs on her walks. Rewards can be treats or a toy that she really loves, anything that gets her to look to you to release that tension she feels seeing another dog and not being able to greet it.
Take it step by step.
Snf
PS: Here is the Suzanne Clothier article called "He Just Wants to Say Hi". I bring it up here since it is pertinent in regard to behavior.
www.nesr.info/images-english-shepherd/He-just-wants-to-say-hi.pdf
Both Haru and my mom's shelter mix will bait other dogs with treats or food. That's not abnormal. Then they'll make play growls as they try to keep the item away from the other dog. The difference is they pretty much know the line between when it's being taken as play and when it might be taken as serious. I've never seen these games turn into an argument and someone always gives before the other gets upset. To me it really sounds like your dog is making normal attempts to initiate play but is adding a bit too much aggressive response and being a bit too pushy about it because she doesn't know what is appropriate and respectable behavior and what may start a fight. Haru started to have the same problem and I worried about it but like I said she quickly learned after being properly disciplined by other well socialized dogs.
Ki was almost 2 years old when I adopted him so he was a pretty hard nut to crack.
My advice would be:
1. Training classes, training classes, training classes! Young dogs, especially, benefit from being in an environment where they can learn commands, learn to relax around other dogs, and learn to play (as was said) with a trainer as a referee.
2. Exercize! I'm not going all Cesar Milan on you but high-energy dogs (like my Ki) are easier to work with when they don't have so much pent up energy. I also walk him with a pack to help him keep focused (he gets into work mode...it's awesome). If he hasn't been out for awhile or is too excitable, I'll wait on letting him approach other dogs until we've finished a very decent walk to work him out. Then he can usually approach in a bit calmer manner. The pack also deters him from jumping as much since the weight can make that awkard.
3. Don't reward pulling! Your dog pulls on the leash because there is another dog. You reward this behavior by bringing them or being dragged to the other dog. Good leash behavior is very important. Work on having your dog be able to walk on a loose leash. Know how to get your dog's attention. Ki used to pull to go see another dog. I would stop the behavior by stopping the walk. I would stop and he would have to sit to wait. When he calmed down I would give him his release command ('okay!') and then we'd walk. If he pulled ahead we would stop, if he behaved we would make progress to go see the other dog. I would also make him sit/stay before approaching the other dog...*even* if the other dog approaches him he is supposed to wait until I tell him it's okay.
4. Pick good playmates! When Ki is in sit/stay, I ask the owner if it is okay for Ki to say hi and *explain* that my dog likes to jump and pounce (yes...Ki i the bastardy dog that superman-leap-punches your dog with both paws and then runs away in the hope that he'll be chased). Some dogs don't tolerate this *at all*. Hopefully the other owner knows their dog well enough to let you know that so you can let them say hi from a distance and move on to the next playmate if you know your dog can't adjust their play level. Be a good judge, correct, reward and don't be afraid to talk to other owners and be honest. And until you have basic commands down, it might be best to skip the dog park.
Your dog is still young so this will likely be a lot simpler than you think once you get into puppy classes, but just remember that if you are consistent and patient you can make it work even with older dogs.
i do the sit and stay and he listens but then i say okay and he runs up to the dog just as excited, so looks like i'm not following through with the idea behind the training
to add my question to this thread,
I notice toki will invade a dog's personal space, bypassing the sniff hello, if the other dog barks then he starts growling and snarling barking but if the other dog is okay toki is okay
so how do I get him to learn to back down from the other dog's threat and back away? rather than challenge it by remaining and barking?
or am i reading this whole thing wrong?