Allergic to Cats but not Dogs?

edited January 2009 in General
I am incredibly allergic to cats, I didn't use to be when I was a kid, it came on all of a sudden when I was around 11.


Now, I've been around dogs a ton, but mostly outside, so when I went to the dog show, I was afraid allergies would manifest themselves...after all, a room filled with a hundred dogs....


but nope, nothing! Not a tear, not a sneeze, my eyes were clear...it's like there were no dogs there at all.



Is that really possible, to be allergic to cats but not dogs? Or am I just a weirdo? lol



[ ok, MORE of a weirdo :p ] ~

Comments

  • edited January 2009
    Being allergic to cats, but not dogs is very common -- my wife, my brother, and son all share that. Cat dander contains a different allergen than dog dander. Cat dander is also much, much smaller, making it disperse more easily and pervasively in the environment. FYI, not all cat dander is equal in its potency. Male cat dander tends to have a higher concentration of the protein that causes the reaction, and dark haired cats have more than lighter haired cats. So if you're allergic, stay away from black, male cats. ; )
  • edited November -1
    If a cat so much as rubs up against my leg I'll be miserable for hours. But I have no problems with dogs.
  • edited November -1
    same here - during kitten season and long days at the shelter, I have to arm myself with Zyrtec but with dogs I've never had an issue.
  • edited November -1
    Oh, yay! So I'm not the only one haha :) ~
  • edited January 2009
    so, per Kojichan's knowledge of dander, I'd be less affected by a white female cat than a male black one?
    How interesting is THAT? I never knew that!
    What about the LaPerm or Siberian claims of being "hypo[not non]allergenic"?
  • edited November -1
    I don't think any cat / dog is hypoallergenic, as dander comes more from the skin than the fur. [ ? ]


    I know Sphynx Cat's are NOT hypoallergenic, even tho they have no fur.




    Kittens don't bother me as much as full grown cats. :) ~
  • edited November -1
    Certain breeds of dog are known to be less allergy-triggering than others. (eg poodles)

    There could be breeds of cat that are the same? I dunno. I'm not up on my cat breeds.
  • edited November -1
    Some dog breeds have been promoted as hypoallergenic because they do not shed their hair, shed very little, or have the same pH as human hair. However, no canine is known to be completely nonallergenic. Poodles and Poodle hybrids are commonly mistaken as being hypoallergenic, when in reality they are known to cause different forms of allergies, including bronchitis, as does any breed of dog.

    Cat breeds such as the LaPerm, Sphynx, Devon Rex and Cornish Rex, which lack some or all of the normal layers in cats' fur, are believed by mild allergy sufferers to be significantly less likely to provoke an allergic reaction than other breeds. Siberian cats and Russian Blue are also believed by some to have such properties.

    There is only one known hypoallergenic horse breed. The Bashkir Curly horse has a uniquely textured coat that lacks the protein (present in all other horse fur) believed to be the source of allergic reactions to equines. Many people with severe allergies to horses can handle Bashkir Curlies with no reaction.

    From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypoallergenic
  • edited November -1
    The same thing happened to me. I developed an allergy to cats at around 10 years old. It sucked because I would stay at my friends house after school until around 6 when my mom got out of work and they had a cat. His name was Splinters and I was totally fine until one day BAM! My face got all blotchy and my eyes were itching like crazy and I couldn't stop sneezing. Never had a problem with dogs though, thank goodness.
  • edited November -1
    From what I've heard, part of being allergic to cats comes from the saliva, as it has a greater concentration of cat allergens. Cats, unlike dogs, lick themselves as if it were their life's mission, spreading their saliva all over their body. That saliva dries and flakes off all over the house.

    With the hypoallergenic dogs, they can actually shed pretty much equal to regular dogs if given the chance. Look at your own hair, you'll find bits and pieces of it through out your home. Most of the dogs with hair usually get groomed about every month or two, thus anything that needs to be shed gets washed away at the groomers or in the bath tub. I have seen people who are allergic to cats own quite a fluffball. They routinely vacuum the house and bath the cat on a weekly basis. Long haired cats actually drop less hair than short haired cats, since the majority of the shedded hair gets tangled with the rest, thus causing mats when not brushed.
  • edited November -1
    I am allergic to both and have both...the miracles of modern medicine....
  • edited January 2009
    Oh, don't get me wrong Jess, it wouldn't have stopped me anyway!!!


    lol :D ~
  • edited November -1
    My son is allergic to cats.... it struck him for the first time with a vengeance just about the time he was six, and coincidentally, just about the time I thought I might succumb to his desire and get him a pet cat. Then we went onward petless for another 8-9 years (except for the hamster and that snake and that bunny)... I thought being petless was a good thing at the time. Siamese seem to be the worst for him, but none are good. My daughter's three cats (inluding one Siamese) now live with us. It has reduced my son to visiting us with his inhaler in hand. He claims dogs do not bother him (at least most of the time). He has to use the inhaler at other times, too... bad air days (seems like there are a lot more of those these days here in the city), fall ragweed season (a MN favorite (NOT) among allergy sufferers), and lighter doses in the spring when the plant pollens and "under the snow molds" get revealed simultaneously...

    That's about it for my knowledge of allergies! Seems like our family was (not so) lucky to get them mostly concentrated in one family member!
  • edited November -1
    who wants to take Zyrtec 24/7?

    I would love to own a cat, but I realize that either means finding a specific breed (I've been to a LaPerm cattery and sneezed only once) and not adopting or downing zyrtec, sudafed or benedryl for the rest of forever. Neither is something I want to do, so I don't own a cat... but we did foster cats for 1-2 weeks at a time in the spring. I won't be doing that this year, though. I know that orange tabbies and tuxedo cats really get me sneezing and coughing and runny everything.

    Also, thats the info I found, too, Kyla - especially the part about siberian/russian blue/Norwegian forest cats... but my neighbor has a russian blue, and his fur is on everything!!
  • edited November -1
    My mom has two Russian blues and they really do shed a lot. More than the black and white cats we have. I'm really not good with cat types.
  • edited November -1
    I am allergic to both cats and dogs, have been since I was a kid, but I think I have outgrown it for the most part since I refuse to live without dogs and cats in my life. I still get a little itchy every once in a while, but nothing a benadryl won't take care of.
  • edited November -1
    I am allergic to cats and dogs, but I have become used to both Toby and Coda's dander ( and I haven't taken my allergy meds in years ). I think I am starting to grow out of it. I think I was only reacting when we first brought Toby home. But, it is a whole other story if I go to friend's houses ( and they have cats or dogs or both ). I'm fine at night, but I wake up the next morning with the worst runny nose and such. :(

    Coda rubs his body/butt/tail all over me when I am home, and I never have had any reaction to it.
  • edited November -1
    My friends claim to be allergic to cats... that's why they do not want to come over (meanies). We bring Sasuke over their place though.

    My vet told me a story about her daughter: "Dad, when I get older, I will buy a house and have a room installed where you can go in, but my cats will not be allowed to go." lol
  • edited November -1
    Awww that's too cute Joe! haha Kids are hysterical sometimes. :) ~
Sign In or Register to comment.