Female versus Male

edited April 2010 in General
When looking at dogs and toying with the idea of other breeds...


...I seem to "gravitate" towards males. Unless I'm personally interested in breeding (i.e. Malinois & Shikoku)...I look into getting males so that the breeder I acquired said breed from could use him as stud for their kennel's breeding program. I figure, if I'm going to do all sorts of training and titling on the dog anyways...someone should get some puppies out of that dog! lol.


However, if males seem more dominant in the competive world of said sport/venue, I start graviting towards females because I feel that more females should be titled and to the highest degree/level!


When looking for a dog...what is your motivation for gender?

Comments

  • edited November -1
    I lean towards males, Errik lean towards females. Not sure of why though, the ones we connect best with happens to be of that particular gender.
  • edited November -1
    I tend to prefer females, unless the male has that "gentle giant" quality. There is always room in my life for a dog like Hilo.
  • edited November -1
    After thinking a bit, I don't think I am drawn to one over the other. Individual personality and breed personality trumps gender tendencies for me. If I had no dogs, and was seeking one I'd consider either sex if we connect. Since I have one of each already, and have to consider their (esp Sage's) comfort and quirks, I would look for a female next- just because the dogs Sage really PLAYS with happen to be females- but I would be easily swayed by a male with a more compatible personality over a less compatible female.
  • edited November -1
    That's an interesting question.

    I think I basically agree with Chrys. I've found myself drawn to both male and female dogs of various breeds. It ultimately comes down to the individual temperament of the dog.

    I will say that visually, especially when it comes to the NK, I tend to prefer males. There's something about their proportions and stockier build that I tend to gravitate to. When it comes to choosing a dog to spend my time with, sex is of less of a concern though.
  • edited November -1
    I always look at the quality of the dog, their personality, attributes, working ability and drives...but if I'm picking between 2 pups of either gender and they're both "the same"...that individual's dog's purpose (what am I going to do with this dog?) comes into account, as well as which might be a better fit within the existing pack.


    You only get 2 options to choose from =p...but it is always fun to think about and ponder. Within my choosen breeds, I find myself not caring so much about female or male...I'd be happy with either...if the dog is good, the dog IS good! This goes for ANY breed, but when I start looking at more "off-breed" dogs I find myself pre-selecting a gender for that particular breed and then searching and searching and searching until I find the quality I'm looking that matches my "pre-selection".


    When I thought about this, I found it kinda of interesting...
  • edited November -1
    I have heard that people who do dog sports run males more often because females in heat aren't allowed at many events, (or they can go last, I guess?) and females also take time out having puppies and recovering from having puppies, which gives males more days they can work & more training time. Males' breeding duties never take them out of the action. Does that seem to bear out, Corina? That it's not that the females can't or aren't appreciated, its just that the training, travel and performance load is more profitably invested in running and titling a male?
  • edited November -1
    For me, I prefer females as far as when planning on getting a dog and living with them. However, I've chosen male dogs before to bring home before just because I liked their temperment better. That's what usually ends up happening when I go to the shelter to get a new dog, we go looking for a female and come home with a male just because he fit our lifestyle better and overall seemed like a great dog.
  • edited November -1
    I actually prefer females because they seem to take to hunting faster and easier then males although its not so bad with males either. Although Yuki didn't really take to hunting much but Hana is a super duck/pheasant dog. She started strong as a bird dog with very basic training and she has out hunted my last bird dogs Monk and Woody. Both of my male Kishus took to hunting really well although Taro is still a rookie but shows tons of potential. My next NK's will most likely be females since I wold like to get Taro's puppies.
  • edited November -1
    When I choose it comes down to what I want that dog's role to be and the dynamic of the current dogs in similar or the same roles. That's always my first concern. After that, assuming either sex would work for the role (which is usually not the case) I would pick a male. I way prefer the temperament of male dogs, they are way more chill than females... This is, of course, skewed by the number of dogs we have. I find my self drawn more to independent lower maintenance dogs, and in my experience males are lower maintenance, more relaxed, and more independent than females.

    But, when you start to filter the selection through the "role" filter, my opinion starts to change. For example, I would rather have a male/female pair for guarding. So if I was selecting a guardian to work with another guardian I would choose one of the opposite sex (female in this example) even if I prefer a male. Also, if I was looking for a dog to hike with, I would probably lean toward a female over a male due to them being less likely to roam. These are the types of things that come first for me...

    But for sure, if there were no "role" or social concerns then I would pick a male. Which is strange, since females tend to bond better with me than males. :oT

    ----
  • edited November -1
    Just a preference sort of thing, I tend to prefer males. There is really no particularly reason for it, other than the fact that males tend [ not always ] to be bigger [ I like big dogs ] & the thought of when to spay vs how many heats to go through plays a big role.

    IE: A male is a lot easier to keep intact than a female would be, I think. I also hear empty heats are hard on females so it's better to spay them early if they're not being bred...but then the idea of how early is too early comes into play...it's kind of stressing me out haha

    Tho, most of the animals I've owned in my lifetime have been males. From the iguana, to birds, to Snake, to Rabbit. Most of the friends & co-workers I get on well with are guys too...lol

    But, that said, I've met some really awesome female doggies. [ I will always be forever trying to convince Brad & Jen to send me Ahi :p ] My favorite Rottie in the world was from when I was a kid was female, Eva.

    That said, I prefer males, but I've come to realize my major preference for males comes from the fact that they tend to be easier to "maintain." [ talking about the spay thing here again ]

    I guess it doesn't really matter, so long as the dog / bitch has a temperament that suits you & your lifestyle :)

    ---
    Also, this isn't really a reason but...I can list about 100 names I'd like to give to my male pups, but we can only come up with 2 for a female LOL I guess I like boy names more than girl names haha ~
  • edited November -1
    Chrystal,

    "I have heard that people who do dog sports run males more often because females in heat aren't allowed at many events, (or they can go last, I guess?)..."


    - In the dog sports that I've been involved with, the females are allowed to trial during their heat cycle but they must go last. And I often find for those who would like to keep their dogs intact that the whole bleeding process (though "short") is a bit too much for most people to deal with. Then there's a possibility of some feminine (sp?) doggie odor =). I haven't notice any major difference in Lynx's working ability (other then she might get even sharper and more intense) but I guess some females might not work up to their full potiental [don't know if it happens to dogs but I would just *assume* yeah...think cramps!].


    "and females also take time out having puppies and recovering from having puppies, which gives males more days they can work & more training time. Males' breeding duties never take them out of the action."


    - I guess it might depend on the breeder and that kennel's breeding schedule/lifestyle (how many litters they want out of the female = how much actual "off-time" the dog will require). I suppose most require "time off" for pregnancy and whelping. I believe that *most* breeders/owners/handlers would start going back to their regular training schedule as soon as Mama has finished her 8th week of raising the pups. Some breeders continue to work (and even trial if not against "the rules") their females through pregnancy until the female hits a certain *peak point* in the pregnancy and requires rest and preparation for whelping (kinda like humans working their jobs through most of their pregnancy until they get closer to giving birth and need to relax). Other breeders might even take Mama out for training or trials as soon as the 5th week or so...though this is not as commonly practice I don't think.


    "Does that seem to bear out, Corina? That it's not that the females can't or aren't appreciated, its just that the training, travel and performance load is more profitably invested in running and titling a male?"


    - It looks as if you have a pretty good idea of it ;).
  • edited November -1
    I tend to like males better too. My preference has been built from vast generalizations over a variety of dogs of different breeds, and I'm aware it may simply come down to the individual dogs, but in general, I've experienced more difficult females--more aggressive, often harder to handle. I wonder if this is also because many of the females I knew were females spayed quite early....Though that said, my family had an intact GSD bitch as a kid who was utterly out of control aggressive towards people (though good with me as a kid). At that time, my mother, who knew nothing about dogs, thought her wild aggression was a good thing...ie. protective....though now it scares me to think about how untrained and super aggressive that dog was.

    anyway, I don't know that I have a really good reason for my preference....it's probably more based on the dogs I've had.
  • edited November -1
    I'm completely with Osy on this one. Those are the same exact reasons why I prefer males over females
  • This is a interesting thread! It was really nice to know other people's reasons. I really want to be a part of this too :D Ha! I lean towards the male more because of many reasons. I really love my dogs to reflect me. So I'm going to brag a little bit about myself here but it's the honest truth from my heart :P. I personally believe I have a very strong drive for things...if I want something I will do everything to have it. I'm also a very energetic person. I love to do a ton of running and weight lifting. I love to train and push myself to the point where I would collapse to the ground. I love to compete and I love to be the best! I am an year round outdoor person. I love the nature and the wildlife. I love the evil and tough features. I guess to me the males seems to be more wild and have more of a stocky, tough and bold look. I guess it's just my preference but I love tough dogs. When it comes to choosing a female I will select one that has a tougher look. The females that I love are the ones that looks like a male. I guess you can put it this way...if I were to be a dog...that's how I would want to look :). I'll let my girlfriend/future wife be the one to add the cute, friendly looking dogs to the family.
  • Funny thing, it hasn't even been a year since I responded to this thread and my answer has changed.

    I'm leaning towards the females as much as I lean towards the males. A lot more factors are considered to figure out which way I'll fall.
  • Wow totally forgot about this thread.

    I still prefer males over females. But if a female puppy came up that had the temperment and personality I was looking for I would highly consider and probably take the female over the male pup.
  • Well, I never saw this thread earlier. But I generally prefer the male temperament over a female. But again, each dog does have individuality too.
  • Ha ha! @yiasthoj the qualities you have described as favoring, in my experience describe most of the female NK I know. My Shikoku (female) is more confrontational, more bold, and more active than my male shiba was or my male akita is.The only thing I would say that is within your description of feminine would be her size as she is smaller than the male standard.

    As far as preference I hold fast to my preference for female dogs. In my experience I have found them to be the more dynamic and bold personalities. As far as toughness goes, my female shikoku is likely the toughest. But that said my dogs all rely on each other. Each one has things that make them nervous and I find the others will compensate for the dog who is nervous. If on the rare occasion, all are nervous they turn to me. I enjoy adult male dogs. Young males are tiresome to me. I find this all to be true of humans as well. Young men tend to bore me with their displays and behavior. I prefer the reserved confidence of adult men. I am more tolerant of young females. In general I guess I prefer adults of all species.

    I must say, tough dogs outside of working dogs are just silly to me. To me what makes an owner seem formidable, and impressive is their desire to love and protect their animals. When a big strong dog feels safe and at peace with their owner that, to me, says that that owner is strong and confident and has earned their dogs respect. Considering a chihuahua can crush bones in a human hand, we as a species tend to forget that dogs CHOOSE to listen to us, and CHOOSE to be our companions. So my belief is the sweeter the dog the stronger the owner.
  • I really have no preference. Noah once said that he prefers females because they don't have penises, lol. Although, we've had male dogs and it didn't really end up bothering him.
  • @JessicaRabbit, lol...I knew I didn't know crap about what I was talking about LOL...you're right, I agree with you 100%. I have never had a female dog before so I only know one side of the story and of only one dog. I basically took a wild guess on how a female dog might be like. I am so sure I will fall in love with the females once I have one. I guess I'm kind of a crazy person and likes wild, crazy, and independent animals. Oh and I agree with you about the sweeter the dog the stronger the owner. The dog I have right now is a little bit wild and nutty sometimes and I can't really control or calm him down at times...and I do feel like I'm pretty weak for not being able to control such a small dog... All I can say is that my little buddy has a stronger and bigger heart than mine. Safety and the health of my dog is the most important thing to me.
Sign In or Register to comment.